DEI (Diversity, Equality and Inclusion).

Did a backlash against woke culture contribute to the election of Donald Trump in 2024?

One serious point - touched upon in one or two of the comments to the EFDSS article on folk dancing in the UK  - is that many 'ordinary people' in the USA have rebelled against 'woke culture'. Many of these 'ordinary people', including large numbers who have little personal wealth, nevertheless voted for Donald Trump in 2024 as a protest against 'the system'. Tens of millions of women also voted for Trump, including many who disliked him as a person, but disliked the idea of Kamala Harris as president even less. Polls suggested that many American women were not yet ready for a woman as president.

Some commentators have even suggested that were it not for 'woke culture' having been forced upon the mass of the US population over many years, the world might never have experienced a second Trump presidency. The election result was certainly in some degree the result of a strong protest vote against 'the system' by people who felt they were being ignored. As with Brexit in the UK, many people who voted in this way were probably in the socio-economic groups who may suffer the most negative consequences of the second Trump presidency.

The argument that the imposition of 'wokeness' (political correctness) has advantaged Trump and similar politicians goes back at least to 2016, the date of Trump's first election victory. There are many references on the internet, including this one. It counters some of the arguments made by other authors, who try to deny such a connection. It is, after all, a bitter pill for left of centre Democrats to swallow to realise that some of their cherished if misguided ideas (and ideals) helped to produce what could be the most right wing US presidency in living memory.

Many people within the environmental movement (and I count myself amongst them) now foresee a period of potentially damaging policies and programmes across the globe - from the Amazon to Alaska, many of which may prove to have irreversible consequences for Life on Earth.



"We will stop left wing cancel culture. It's very simple. very simple."

 

Many people who voted for Trump might also have had some environmental sentiments, but their priorities on voting day in 2024 were to identify with outspoken criticism of 'wokeness'. Away from the privacy of the voting booth, they felt powerless to protest, in part from fear of being labelled a social pariah, or even subject to arrest and detention.

It is true also that many people help to fund 'extreme' environmental organisations such as Sea Shepherd or Greenpeace, whilst being in fear of undertaking direct actions themselves. The logic is the same - people pay or elect other people to do or say the things they feel unable to do or say themselves.

These arguments are made and remade in many of the references on the internet. In short, many 'ordinary' working class Americans felt sufficiently repressed by the imposition of 'woke' dogma and 'cancel culture' that they took an opportunity to lash out against its proponents - identified as members of the Democratic Party.

An interview with Elon Musk on the 'woke-mind' virus, the benefits of free speech, and meritocracy is here. It predates DOGE and his association with Trump2, but includes a discussion of the risks of cancel-culture. Also ranges over resource depletion and AI.

 



 

 

"The second most precious thing in life is the right to express yourself freely."

In the UK also there is a long history of fear of speaking out - well documented by the millionaire comedian Rowan Atkinson in this video - and dating from 2013/2014. It is no surprise the the veteran MP, Rt Hon David Davies, was one of the supporters of this campaign.

Quote from Sir Niall Ferguson abstracted from https://archive.ph/AWWC8 , an article in The Times (UK) 7 January 2025, centred upon the 2024 re-election of Donald Trump as president of the USA.

A large article by the same author and dealing with the decline in academic freedom in US and UK universities was published on 1 March 2025. It is archived here - and is centred upon the author's denunciation of 'wokeness' and cancel culture.

Entitled: How EDI, cancel culture and bad boards are killing our universities.
Sub title: With British institutions copying the likes of Harvard in stifling free speech, the only way back to reason is explicit guarantees for academic freedom.


 

 

Extracts from the CNN report (published July 2021) cited below.

The 'woke' pendulum has arguably swung too far. The reaction against it can be seen in the extremes of (for example) CPAC in the USA.

Back in 2016, as well as in the mid-term elections of 2021/2022,there were concerns that the left of the Democratic party in the USA were losing votes to the GOP (Republicans).

This report (extracts in left panel) discusses the risks in the mid term USA elections - and the risk was still there in 2024, despite post-2024 election pleadings by left-wing commentators that 'wokeness did not produce Trump2'.

Personally, and having experienced the petty minded 'cancel culture' associated with folk dance zealots in the UK, I am not convinced. Within UK society as a whole, there is widespread and deep-seated hostility to the excesses of the 'woke' agenda:


Home page.

Top of Sidmouth Festival section

woke1 - including the EFDSS proclamation that all dancing should henceforth be gender neutral.

woke2 - examples of where the imposition of gender neutral dancing disadvantages and discourages a majority of folk dancers